Can You Trust the Number?


The number is the result. The more important question may be what went into it.
There comes a point in almost every land deal when an earthwork number stops being something on a spreadsheet and becomes something somebody has to act on.
It may influence the land basis. It may become part of the development budget. It may be compared against a contractor's estimate. Eventually, someone has to become comfortable enough with the number to make a decision.
That is why I've become less interested in asking whether an earthwork number is simply right or wrong. I want to know what it's built on.
A recent project with one of our longtime homebuilder clients was a good example. We weren't starting with a finished grading plan. We had existing conditions, a preliminary plat, updated roadway requirements and pieces of the proposed design.
Before calculating quantities, we talked through the project. How much are we stripping? What should we carry for shrink? What material are we likely dealing with? What's happening with the roadway section? What about utility spoils? How are the pads being handled? What's happening with the ponds?
None of those questions by themselves are particularly dramatic. Together, they become the foundation of earthwork estimates.
When the Number Changes the Land Conversation
Imagine a property is under contract and the early budget assumes the site is reasonably close to balanced. Then an independent earthwork review identifies another 50,000 cubic yards of potential import.
At an illustrative planning figure of $25 per cubic yard, that's roughly $1.25 million of potential exposure. It isn't a construction estimate, but it is enough to change the conversation around a deal.
If the land team is going back to the seller, simply having a different quantity isn't enough. They need to understand what created the difference.
Was it proposed elevation? Strip depth? Shrink? Pond geometry? Material suitability? A roadway section? Or something that wasn't included in the original number?
There's a big difference between saying, “Our dirt number went up,” and being able to explain, “Here's what's driving the difference, and here's why we believe it's reasonable.”
The second conversation gives the land team something they can actually use. It may affect the land basis, change the contingency carried into the deal, or simply help the team decide that the additional exposure is understood and acceptable.
When Two Numbers Don't Match
The same issue shows up when contractor pricing enters the picture. A contractor may be carrying significantly more import than the owner expected, or the owner's early model may show something different from the contractor's estimate.
That doesn't automatically mean either side is wrong.
Consider a project with 200,000 cubic yards of compacted fill demand. A 10% difference represents 20,000 cubic yards. At the same illustrative $25-per-yard planning figure, that's roughly $500,000.
The math isn't the hard part. The important question is: What's driving the difference?
Maybe one side handled shrink differently. Maybe stripped material was considered reusable in one number and not the other. Maybe proposed elevations changed.
Once those differences are visible, the conversation becomes much more productive. Instead of our number versus your number, everyone can look at what each number is built on.
The objective isn't to prove somebody wrong. It's to understand the difference before deciding which number belongs in the budget.
Sometimes the Best Result Is Nothing Changed
Sometimes we build the model, work through what's driving the dirt position, test the pieces that matter and end up very close to where the land team started.
That's a good result.
One of our longtime clients describes the process to new members of his land team as some of the “cheapest insurance” they can have on a deal.
You don't buy insurance because you expect something to go wrong. You buy it because the consequence matters enough that protection is worthwhile.
Independent earthwork analysis can work the same way. Sometimes it identifies something that changes the budget or the land conversation. Sometimes it raises a question that deserves more investigation.
And sometimes it tells the team: The number you were carrying makes sense.
That may not be dramatic, but when someone is preparing to make a multimillion-dollar land decision, confirmation can have real value.
The Number Is the Result
An earthwork number can look very precise on a spreadsheet: 187,000 yards. 143,000 yards. 96,000 yards.
But those numbers are the result of project conditions and decisions underneath them: strip depth, shrink, material suitability, proposed elevations, roadway sections, pond geometry, pad elevations and utility spoils.
On the recent project I mentioned earlier, roadway requirements had changed from what had been used on the previous phase. The land team immediately recognized that those changes would affect how much dirt needed to be placed on the lots.
That's a fairly ordinary design change. But roadway sections affect the grading. The grading affects the dirt position. And the dirt position eventually affects the budget.
The same can happen with six inches of stripping, a different shrink factor, a pad elevation or a change in pond geometry.
Small inputs don't always produce small consequences when they're applied across an entire development.
That's why, when I see an earthwork number, I increasingly find myself asking: What went into it?
You Don't Need Certainty
An early earthwork number isn't final. Design changes. Geotechnical information develops. Proposed elevations move. Quantities evolve as engineering progresses.
That's normal.
You don't need to know everything about a site before making an early land decision. But you should understand what your earthwork number is built on—and which pieces have enough leverage to materially change it.
Sometimes that understanding changes the number. Sometimes it changes the conversation with a seller or contractor. Sometimes it confirms that the team was already in the right place.
All three are useful outcomes.
Because eventually somebody has to take the number off the spreadsheet and make a decision with it.
A Question Worth Asking
If someone asked you today, “What is this earthwork number built on?”—could you answer them?
If you understand what went into the number, you're in a much better position to decide what to do with it.
Bill Cheatham
President | Earth Tek
Questions This Issue Explores
What is the earthwork number currently in your budget built on?
Which project inputs have the greatest ability to materially change the dirt position?
If your number differs from a contractor's estimate, do you understand what is creating the difference?
Have design changes occurred since the number was originally developed?
If an independent review came back close to the number you're already carrying, what would that additional confirmation be worth before the next major decision?



Comments